Mike Bain/cvnznews.com
More than 40 of New Zealand’s leading constitutional and electoral experts have signed an open letter calling for reform of the Mixed Member Proportional (MMP) voting system following the unprecedented outcome of the 2026 election.
The election produced an 11-seat overhang, meaning several parties secured more seats in Parliament than their share of the party vote would normally allow. Critics argue the result has distorted the proportional representation that MMP was designed to deliver.
The letter, signed by 46 experts including former Prime Minister Sir Geoffrey Palmer, members of the 2023 Independent Electoral Review, and constitutional academics from universities around New Zealand, warns that the election exposed significant weaknesses in the current system.
The experts say New Zealanders support MMP because it is intended to ensure Parliament reflects the proportion of votes cast nationwide. However, the 2026 outcome allowed some parties to gain parliamentary representation well beyond what their party vote would otherwise justify.
The signatories point to examples where the party finishing second in the party vote would receive more MPs than the party finishing first, while another party secured several times more MPs than its party vote entitlement.
To address these concerns, the group has proposed a range of possible reforms. These include increasing the number of list MPs, reducing the number of electorate seats, combining electorate and party votes to avoid strategic voting distortions, limiting large overhangs, and adjusting parliamentary voting strength to better reflect party vote results.
The letter stresses that no single solution is perfect and acknowledges there is legitimate debate about the best path forward. However, the experts argue that the election result has highlighted a need for change to ensure every vote carries equal weight and that Parliament remains genuinely representative of public support.
The proposed reforms are intended to spark a broader public discussion about how New Zealand’s electoral system can be strengthened while preserving the proportional principles that underpin MMP.






