OPINION: Michael Swanson
46 experts have this week released an open letter to the members of New Zealand’s new Parliament calling for a deep dive into keeping MMP proportional…and I’m on that list. The letter was led by Andrew Geddis, Lara Greaves and Max Rashbrooke, and signed by a further 43 of us who span all sorts of expertise in electoral law, constitutional law, public policy, political science, political theory, and New Zealand politics.
I partly signed on to the letter because of the massive respect I have for some of those behind this letter, but also because I firmly believe in liberal democracy, and proportional representation. Part of my thesis addressed why liberal democracy, and the institutions that support that democracy are so important from both a systems operation perspective, but also from a pure integrity and trust perspective. I still believe in liberal democracy, I still believe in proportional representation, and I still believe MMP can work, but we need to do some fine tuning.
It is important to note, many of us didn’t draft the letter, and we might not agree with 100% of it’s content, but the general vibe and recommendations are broadly in line with what I’ve talked about for a long time, and have written many articles on (especially this year).
Below I give a bit of a breakdown of what was actually in the letter and why.

What is being recommended?
Broadly speaking, we’re actually just calling on Parliament to do what has been recommended several times before in some shape or form – ensure that the proportional electoral system we use remains proportional. The 2026 election has shown that the proportionality part of MMP is at risk, and we need to act quickly to ensure the integrity of the system is maintained, and that trust in proportional representation is restored.
Here’s the key part of our letter, the recommendations for ways to address the issue:
We call on all parties in Parliament to commit to adjusting MMP’s settings this term to safeguard MMP as a proportional system into the future. There are a number of ways to do this and different packages of changes, for example:
- increase the number of list MPs or reduce the number of electorate MPs so that the proportion of list seats in Parliament is higher and can more effectively ensure proportionality between parties
- combine the proportional vote and the vote for your local representative so there is not the same split vote effect
- allow one or two overhang seats per party, but rule out large disproportionate overhangs through the German approach of requiring parties to have enough party votes to cover their electorate wins
- adjust the voting rules in Parliament so a party’s voting strength in Parliament is based on its party vote not its total MPs.
These adjustments to MMP (and other options) each have strengths and weaknesses, and there is legitimate debate as to which is preferable. They should be considered carefully and transparently, with input from the public.
The question then turns to how to go about this:
The best process to consider those options is an urgent select committee inquiry with MPs from all parties in Parliament. The MMP Review Committee (2000-2001) and the Electoral Legislation Committee (2010-2011) provide a model.
Its inquiry should be narrowly focused on this issue and report back by mid-2027 so that a Government Bill can make the necessary changes to the Electoral Act 1993 well before the next General Election. The inquiry should take public submissions, and advice from public servants and experts.
The adjustments to MMP should be principled, based on proportionality and fairness, and acceptable to as many political parties as possible. The Inquiry should look at overseas examples and potential fixes, but also look at what works for New Zealand’s own constitutional arrangements including Te Tiriti o Waitangi/The Treaty of Waitangi.
The recommendations and the potential process aren’t just starting from a zero base. The 1986 Royal Commission, the 2012 MMP Review, and the 2023 Independent Electoral Review all provide information that can be utilised to move forward with a solution, whatever that may be.
Why now?
Never before have we seen an overhang quite like this. But the primary reason for this letter is that we not only have a large overhang, but we have seen campaigns to actively exploit that overhang in a way that, while legal, massively undermines the integrity of our system and our liberal democracy as a whole.
Despite the wailing and gnashing of teeth in social media comment sections, this has nothing to do with who may or may not form government. In fact, a large number of those signed up to this letter have been warning about some of the frailties of MMP for years, decades in some cases. The fact the overhang has been a benefit to national at this election is less of a problem than the shear size of the overhang in general. Several of those who signed the letter have even been part of previous reviews like the 2012 Electoral Commission Review and the 2023 Independent Electoral Review, and both times warned of issues with the overhang long before it got to this size and benefitted those it now does.
So, why now? Because you need to strike while the iron is hot, while it’s front of mind, and while people actually care. One of the issues with previous reviews is that a lack of urgency and political will resulted in the recommendations stagnating and being shelved – we can’t really afford for that to happen again.
What I do worry about is that this will be dealt with in isolation. That even if we do address the overhang, things like campaign finance and coat-tail seats just get forgotten about until a future review recommends they be looked at…again. My hope is that any review is slightly wider and looks at recommendations made by multiple reviews, and addresses them accordingly.







