Sarah McMillan/cvnznews.com
New Zealand nurses are being asked an uncomfortable question: if the Nursing Council couldn’t keep track of its own money, how did it find the cash to drag a veteran nurse through a disciplinary prosecution?
That’s the challenge being posed after an internal audit reportedly found the Nursing Council’s spending controls were rated at the lowest level on the scale, while also highlighting concerns over $1.29 million in potential duplicate payments.
At the same time, the Council was pursuing registered nurse Cath Simpson through the Health Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal over comments posted on her personal social media account.
The apparent contrast has sparked criticism from the Free Speech Union, which says nurses who fund the Council through compulsory fees deserve answers.
According to documents released under the Official Information Act, the Council’s financial reserves have reportedly dropped from $12 million to $4 million. Yet critics point out that resources were still available for a lengthy disciplinary case, including legal representation by King’s Counsel.
The Council sought to have Simpson removed from the nursing profession. While the Tribunal stopped short of that outcome, Simpson was suspended for two months.
For many nurses struggling through staff shortages, rising workloads and cost-of-living pressures, the controversy raises a simple question: where exactly has their money gone?
Free Speech Union Executive Director Jillaine Heather says the Council should prioritise patient safety and financial accountability before policing what health professionals say online in their private capacity.
“Every nurse in New Zealand has to pay the Nursing Council to work,” Heather said. “They deserve transparency about how that money is being spent.”
The organisation is now calling on the Council to reveal the full cost of prosecuting Simpson.
The dispute is likely to reignite the wider debate over free speech, professional regulation, and where the line should be drawn between a practitioner’s private opinions and their professional responsibilities.
One thing is certain: as questions mount over the Council’s finances, many nurses will be watching closely to see whether the regulator that oversees them is prepared to open its own books to public scrutiny.








